Furlough scheme: has employers’ NI been overclaimed?
The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) has issued new guidance that describes two scenarios where employers using the furlough scheme may have inadvertently reclaimed secondary Class 1 NI twice when the scheme was first introduced. What’s the full story?

The Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS) is complex, but broadly employers pay a percentage of an employee's regular salary (at least 80% in 2020), subject to a cap, then reclaim the 80% element from HMRC. However, it also allows secondary Class 2 NI contributions to be reclaimed, as well as pension contributions under auto-enrolment. This has led to some scenarios where employers who claim the employment allowance (EA) of up to £4,000 per year inadvertently receiving furlough payments in respect of NI that is also relieved under the EA. The ICAEW has published detailed commentary on where this may have happened. In brief, an overclaim may occur where:
- EA claims were deferred until after the final claim month for the CJRS where the £4,000 was not absorbed in full during 2020/21; or
- EA claims were made at the beginning of the tax year where the full £4,000 was absorbed before July 2020.
Potentially affected business should carefully read the guidance and contact HMRC’s Employer Helpline on 0300 200 3200 if they think there is an issue.
Related Topics
-
VAT reduced on advance payment if customer cancels?
A subscriber to our newsletter wrote to us with a query. The business supplies a three-stage training course to students that fully pay (non-refundable) in advance for all three stages. If the students drop out before the end, can our subscriber partly reduce the VAT paid to HMRC on their return?
-
HMRC scrutinising directors’ loans
HMRC has begun a new compliance campaign targeting company directors who owed their companies money. What’s the full story, and how should you respond?
-
New two-tier mileage rates for electric vehicles
The amount that employers can reimburse staff for business travel in company cars changes from 1 September 2025. What are the new rates, and why is this update different to previous ones?